Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson, once a dazzling prospect who shattered combine records, finds himself at a pivotal career crossroads. After just three seasons, a trade appears increasingly likely for the young signal-caller this offseason. This situation raises pertinent questions about player development, team expectations, and the volatile nature of professional football careers.
Quarterback Carousel: Richardson's Expected Departure from Indianapolis
In a significant development for the Indianapolis Colts, quarterback Anthony Richardson is anticipated to seek a trade this offseason, according to ESPN's Colts beat writer, Stephen Holder. This move is reportedly driven by Richardson's potential loss of the starting position to Daniel Jones. While an official trade request has yet to be filed, team sources indicate that such an outcome is becoming unavoidable.
Richardson, who dazzled at the combine three years ago and was drafted fourth overall, has had a tumultuous start to his NFL career. Despite his impressive physical attributes – his height, speed, and powerful arm – his on-field performance has been inconsistent. In three seasons, he has made only 15 starts, throwing 11 touchdowns against 13 interceptions. His 2025 season saw him attempt just two passes before landing on the injured reserve list due to a significant orbital bone injury. This lack of consistent playing time and development, particularly his limited experience running a passing offense, has raised concerns about his long-term viability as a starting quarterback.
The Colts, meanwhile, are reportedly planning to re-sign Daniel Jones, who is recovering from a torn Achilles, and designate him as their primary starter. They also intend to bring in Riley Leonard as a backup option, further solidifying Richardson's likely exit. While Richardson is a former first-round pick and will be only 24 years old next season, his trade value remains a point of discussion. Precedents exist for quarterbacks like Kenny Pickett, Sam Howell, Justin Fields, and Taylor Heinicke being traded for draft compensation, suggesting the Colts could still recoup some value.
For teams like the Los Angeles Rams, who are in search of a successor to Matthew Stafford without expending a first-round draft pick, Richardson's availability presents an intriguing, albeit risky, proposition. However, the Rams' offensive system, which thrives on a high level of quarterbacking akin to Stafford's, may not be a suitable fit for Richardson's current developmental stage. His collegiate career at Florida, where he spent only one year as a starter and completed just 54% of his passes, highlights a need for more seasoned experience before handling an NFL-caliber passing attack. Consequently, the expectation of Richardson's trade, or even his potential release if no teams offer draft picks, stems not from his desire to leave, but rather from the challenge of convincing teams that he can effectively contribute at the professional level.
The narrative surrounding Anthony Richardson serves as a potent reminder of the inherent unpredictability in NFL careers, especially for highly touted prospects. While raw talent and physical gifts are undeniable assets, sustained success in professional football demands consistent on-field performance, adaptability, and the ability to stay healthy. Richardson's journey underscores the intricate balance between potential and proven capability, leaving fans and analysts to ponder whether a change of scenery could unlock his full potential, or if his career trajectory is indeed closer to that of a backup with limited game time. Ultimately, his situation highlights the demanding nature of the quarterback position and the high stakes involved in every draft pick.