"I Can Only Imagine 2" revisits the world of Bart Millard, lead singer of the band MercyMe, in an attempt to craft a new inspirational narrative, yet it largely re-treads familiar ground without adding significant depth.
The film, directed by Andrew Erwin and Brent McCorkle, features John Michael Finley reprising his role as Bart, now a successful musician with a family. The plot centers on Bart's ongoing struggle with the emotional scars left by his abusive late father, portrayed in flashbacks by Dennis Quaid. Complicating matters is his strained relationship with his diabetic teenage son, Sam (Sammy Dell), an aspiring musician, whom Bart brings on tour. The arrival of the charismatic singer-songwriter Tim Timmons, played by Milo Ventimiglia, offers a brief respite of humor and lightness, but his character's battle with cancer quickly steers the narrative back towards solemnity. This sequel attempts to tell the origin story of another MercyMe hit, "Even If," but the screenplay struggles to develop a truly engaging plot. The lingering focus on Bart's past trauma feels repetitive, and his son's irresponsible attitude towards his health makes it difficult for viewers to sympathize. The film pivots when Tim's health deteriorates, prompting Bart to complete the song as an anthem of enduring faith.
Ultimately, the movie culminates in Bart's reconciliation with Sam, a bond seemingly solidified over trivial interactions, and a performance of "Even If" at the picturesque Red Rocks Amphitheatre, a scenic choice that deviates from historical accuracy for visual impact. While Ventimiglia and Trace Adkins, returning as the band's manager, deliver commendable performances that inject some much-needed energy, their efforts are insufficient to elevate this laborious and often dull sequel, which many critics view as an uninspired attempt to capitalize on the original's success.
Even when faced with adversity and the temptation to revisit past successes, true artistic integrity lies in moving forward and exploring new avenues for growth and inspiration. While reflecting on personal history can be valuable, rehashing narratives without fresh perspectives risks diminishing the impact of the original story. The pursuit of creative endeavors should prioritize genuine artistic expression over commercial pressures, ensuring that every new creation offers unique value and a resonant message to its audience.